As I mentioned on Tuesday, I don’t do scary, creepy, or horrifying. This week, I’m sharing some of my favorite non-horror Halloween-appropriate reads. Welcome to the third installment of…

Today I’ll be looking at the two classic novels I read for the second Dueling Monsters readalong: The Picture of Dorian Gray by Oscar Wilde (which I read) and The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde by Robert Louis Stevenson (which I listened to). I originally signed up to read The Picture of Dorian Gray but added the other so that I could more fairly proclaim a winner. Neither, thankfully, was the sort of scary I try to avoid, and I would recommend either for some good Halloween reading.

Halloween for the Faint of Heart Badge

Contenders will be judged on four categories: plot, structure, characters, and writing. And now, without further ado, let the battle begin!

Dueling Monsters 2

Category 1: Plot

I won’t summarize these two novels here. Instead, clicking on the titles in the paragraph above will take you to a Goodreads synopsis for the corresponding book.

Both stories are rather imaginative, though I already knew the story of Jekyll and Hyde before reading it. Personally, I enjoyed the slower pace of the longer novel (Dorian) to the quick progression of the shorter (Jekyll). In Jekyll, you are never allowed to forget that you are busy uncovering the mystery of Henry Jekyll and Edward Hyde. It’s like all the extra story fat has been trimmed away. By contrast, Dorian feels more like a novel. There is the peculiar situation of the main character which runs throughout, but there is plenty of superfluous banter and opera viewing as well. Personally, I rather enjoy having the story fat in there to cushion the narrative a bit. It makes the novel feel more real and less isolated.

Winner in the Plot category: The Picture of Dorian Gray

Category 2: Structure

The Picture of Dorian Gray progresses chronologically, beginning when Dorian Gray is rather young and following him through the beginning of his adult years. We observe what happens to him as it occurs, not knowing at the story’s beginning where it will lead us in the end.

In contrast, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde is told through conversations, letters, and journals. When we meet Mr. Utterson, the lawyer through whose eyes we witness the tale, he has already noticed strange things happening. As he fills in the gaps, we begin to piece together the events that have already occurred.

As a means to build suspense, I thought the structure of Jekyll was more effective. Utterson is something of a detective, gathering information and piecing it together to uncover what has happened to his dear friend, Henry Jekyll. The reader knows from the start that something horribly odd is going on. With Dorian, it isn’t until part way into the novel that the reader realizes something is amiss.

Winner in the Structure category: The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde

Category 3: Characters

Because of its short timeline and compact style, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde had little room for character development. Besides Utterson and a couple of others, the characters are met only through letters, stories, or the briefest of encounters. There wasn’t much in any character to latch onto, and so I felt myself listening along with interest but without much sympathy or attachment.

The Picture of Dorian Gray, on the other hand, had splendid characters. There is, of course, Dorian Gray, whose development is the main interest of the story. I loved the contrast between public Dorian, dressed to the nines and the favorite of society ladies, and private Dorian, plagued by personal demons. There is also Basil Halliward, Dorian’s painter friend, who pops in and out of the story. And then there is Lord Henry, my very favorite. At the start of the story, I was ready to strangle the man for his steady stream of one- and two-liners. But as the novel progressed–and especially after Dorian began to change–I came to adore Lord Henry. With Dorian as a foil, Henry appears nothing but a harmless gentleman who enjoys hearing himself talk. I found him endearing.

Winner in the Characters category: The Picture of Dorian Gray

Category 4: Writing

The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde is mostly narration; there isn’t much dialogue. Instead, there are letters and journal entries that express the various characters’ voices and experiences. The writing is stark, the tone matter-of-fact with overtones of the kind of horror that causes one to shudder, not shriek.

I can’t resist sharing this little nugget of…um…wit? which Utterson thinks to himself while staking out Hyde:

“If he be Mr. Hyde, I shall be Mr. Seek.”

Ohhhhhh. That makes me cringe. Seriously, Robert? Did you name your character “Hyde” just so you could work in that line?

The Picture of Dorian Gray was definitely heavier on dialogue. I attribute that to the fact that Wilde was primarily a playwright. I especially loved the silly, snappy banter that inevitably materialized whenever wealthy minor characters gathered. Where there was description, I thought it was lovely. For example:

“The sullen murmur of the bees shouldering their way through the long unmown grass, or circling with monotonous insistence round the dusty gilt horns of the straggling woodbine, seemed to make the stillness more oppressive. The dim roar of London was like the bourdon note of a distant organ.” (p. 1)

“The moon hung low in the sky like a yellow skull. From time to time a huge misshapen cloud stretched a long arm across and hid it. The gas-lamps grew fewer, and the streets more narrow and gloomy….The side-windows of the hansom were clogged with a grey-flannel mist.” (p. 209-210)

I love how clearly both passages evoke their respective settings. Jekyll just didn’t have anything that could compete.

The only strike against Dorian was chapter 12, the dreaded collections chapter. I had to skim. It was way too long. I do have to say, though, that it did produce the feeling that time was passing in the story.

Winner in the Writing category: The Picture of Dorian Gray

And the winner is…

Dueling Monsters: Dorian Gray

With a score of three to one, I hereby declare

The Picture of Dorian Gray

the winner of Dueling Monsters: Round Two!

If you missed the previous Halloween for the Faint of Heart posts, you can find them here:

Your Turn!

Who is your favorite classic monster? Why do you love him/her so much?

Join the Conversation


  1. I didn’t really like Dorian. I found the dialog tiresome and I didn’t like any of the characters! But I haven’t read J&H for probably a decade, so I’d have to reread it see what I think. I like how you declare a winner (even though I’d probably assign different winners for each category!!)

    1. I can definitely see where Dorian would be unlikeable. I thought I was going to hate all the characters too, but then suddenly…I didn’t!

      It’s been really interesting to read everyone’s Dueling Monsters posts. Everyone has such different opinions and preferences! I don’t know if you like audiobooks, but the J&H version read by Martin Jarvis was quite well done and just under 3 hours.

  2. I love Lord Henry!! I love that you eventually came to see him just as he was. On the other hand, that Hyde & Seek line is one of my very favorites – it’s just so silly and ridiculous, something you can imagine internally thinking and cringing at yourself for doing so. ๐Ÿ˜€

    I didn’t feel like the absense of story-fat was a hindrence in J&H. It was a novelette or long short story, rather than a novel, while Dorian was a novella. And actually, the prose in J&H was so much crisper and atmospheric to me, so I thought both had their pluses on that point. Two very different books, exploring very similar themes!

    I don’t mind who wins this round. Both books are excellent!! ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Maybe it was just the way Jarvis read the “Hyde & Seek” line that made it so dreadful to me. Ooh, I cringe just thinking about it!

      I tend to prefer a little story fat. For that reason, I don’t often read short stories, though lately I have found some authors who manage to flesh their short stories out enough for me to really enjoy them. I’d agree that J&H was more atmospheric, but it didn’t grab me the way Dorian did.

      I think I’m just partial to Lord Henry. I’m surprised no one has put together one of those tiny gift books called “Lord Henry’s Guide to Life” or something ๐Ÿ™‚

        1. Aww, he’s not a bad guy! Although now that I know he reminds you of yourself, I’ll be extra careful about borrowing any books you might offer to loan me… ๐Ÿ™‚

  3. I’m so glad you chose The Picture of Dorian Gray. I think this book is rich in so many ways, character and dialogue of course but there are so many interesting themes & the writing is wonderful. It surprised me so how my opinion of Lord Henry changed by the end of the novel. I was also fascinated by the contrast between public & private Dorian. It’s been a while since I read Dorian Gray but your wonderful post has reminded me to pick it up & read it again!

    Another terrific Halloween pick, Erin!

    1. Thanks, Amy! “Rich” is a great word to describe The Picture of Dorian Gray, I think, especially when compared to The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. I know they’re two totally different styles of novel, but I really prefer the richer Dorian Gray style. As for Lord Henry, compared to what Dorian has become in the second half of the book, Henry seems harmless! I got the feeling that, while Dorian had this ugly hidden side, you could take Lord Henry at face value. I appreciated this about him a lot more after watching Dorian’s duality.

      I hope you enjoy your reread, when you get to it!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *