Thoughts on “The Devil in the White City” by Erik Larson (Audiobook)

by Erin on December 7, 2011

I listened to The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson for my book group.

About the Book:

The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson (audiobook cover)In 1893, Chicago hosted an extravagant World’s Fair, nicknamed the White City. A monumental undertaking, the grounds were constructed in under two years, utilizing countless laborers and going so far as to import entire families and even a whole village from other parts of the world. The man in charge of the entire project was Chicago architect Daniel H. Burnham.

While the World’s Fair was under construction, a man who went by the alias H.H. Holmes had set up shop nearby. Underneath his unbelievably charming exterior, Holmes was a serial killer, going about his gruesome activities undetected for far too long.

Though the stories of Burnham and Homes have little in common beyond the time and place they occurred, The Devil in the White City tells the tales in parallel, interspersing chapters of each. Also told is the story of the lunatic who assassinated Chicago’s mayor, Carter Harrison, around the same time, and the entire package is bookended by the Titanic disaster nearly 20 years later.

My Thoughts:

The Devil in the White City is one of those books I’ve been meaning to read for quite some time. I’d heard enough good things to be excited about finally reading it. I already had enough print commitments for the month, so I chose to listen to Larson’s book. Unfortunately, I think this choice, ended up reducing my enjoyment of The Devil in the White City, which I’ll get to in a moment.

Larson really did pack a lot of interesting information into his book. He chronicles the building of the Fair, of course, and spends a little time with each of the Fair’s main players. He also introduces the reader to several of Holmes’s victims before revealing their fates. And then he threw in Harrison’s assassin and the Titanic disaster for good measure. Despite all the stories, I never felt like there was too much going on, and for the most part Larson does a nice job reminding the reader who’s who in the vast sea of historical figures. Larson also succeeds at conveying the scope of the undertaking.

There were moments when I did feel the story dragged. Most often those parts had to do with the Fair’s construction, which was a bit heavy on drier facts and forever progressing a bit only to run into some setback, always with the deadline looming closer. Had I read the book, my group members pointed out, I could have skimmed the slower parts instead of listening to them in full, and I think that would have helped. It also would have allowed me to flip back and remind myself how different people and situations were connected.

My favorite part of The Devil in the White City was seeing the impact the Chicago World’s Fair had on the course of history. Did you know Shredded Wheat was first introduced at the Fair? Or that Walt Disney’s father attended, as did Helen Keller and Theodore Dreiser? Or how about that Mark Twain traveled to Chicago but fell ill and left before he actually saw the Fair? Buffalo Bill Cody, denied a spot in the Fair itself, set up his tent outside and drew at least as many visitors as the Fair itself. The Fair also helped shape the direction of American architecture, among many other things.

My biggest issue with The Devil in the White City on audio was the narrator. The version I listened to was read by Scott Brick. It was my first experience with Brick’s narration, and though I know many people love his audiobooks, I can’t say I’ll be running out to pick another up any time soon. He read so lethargically that it almost sounded like he was falling asleep, and I found myself constantly losing the thread of the story. I finally began listening to the recording at double speed, something I’ve only done once before but which succeeded in bringing the narration up to something like normal speed. A fellow book group member listened to an abridged production by Tony Goldwyn and was much happier!

Those are my thoughts. Check out The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson on Goodreads or LibraryThing, read a plethora of other bloggers’ reviews, or listen to an Audible sample!

Care to share?

You might also like:

Join the conversation!

10 comments
Trisha
Trisha

Yet another book that I have sitting on the to-read shelves... :)

zibilee
zibilee

I bought this book in print from the used bookstore down the street, and haven't had the time to read it yet. It sounds like print is the way to go with this one. It sounds like it was an uneven read for you, which I can understand. I probably wouldn't like all the bits about the fair either. Great review today!

Jennifer, bookspersonally
Jennifer, bookspersonally

I also loved this book... ended up googling old pictures from the fair - amazing! this is a book that might do very well in an "enhanced" version. Very sorry to hear the audio book wasn't very good, could see how that would make or break it.

Ti
Ti

I enjoyed this book. I loved the parts about the fair and how it came to be. The "devil" part was interesting too. That he could have gotten away with it for so long... very interesting. There was a made for TV movie based on the book and it was actually very good.

carol
carol

I loved this book, but I don't think it would have worked for me as an audio.

amanda
amanda

I want to read this sometime, it's been on my list for a while. My dad actually recommended it to me, I think for the architecture portion.

softdrink
softdrink

I love this book, especially all the little facts you learn about the Fair and the "devil's" story. All the background on planning for the Fair got a bit much, but it remains one of my favorite non-fiction reads.

Amanda
Amanda

I have tried this book several times and never gotten past a few chapters. The first few times, I tried in print, and eventually gave up. Then I found out Scott Brick read the audio, and since I do really like him, I tried it, but still didn't get very far. I have no idea how slow he reads normally, since I almost always listen to audiobooks on double speed, and he sounded fine to me, but the book itself was just not worth it. Maybe I could listen to an abridged version, but I just don't feel like abridged versions are worth it, honestly.

Linda
Linda

I found the history fascinating. I really felt like I learned a lot.

Stephanie
Stephanie

I loved this book! I have been meaning to re read it for the past few months. I thought it was very atmospheric.