≡ Menu

Thoughts on “Girl in Translation” by Jean Kwok (Audiobook)

Last month, Em at Love YA Lit reviewed Girl in Translation by Jean Kwok on audio. Her review intrigued me, so I borrowed the audiobook from the library.

About the Book:

Girl in Translation by Jean Kwok (cover)Kimberly Chang and her mother immigrate from Hong Kong to New York when Kimberly is just a girl. Her mother’s older sister, Aunt Paula, sponsors them and pays for their passage over. She finds them an apartment and work. But the apartment is barely livable: the windows in the kitchen are broken, the heat doesn’t work, and roaches and mice are alarmingly bold. The work is hard: long hours in a clothing factory run by Paula and her husband, Bob, where children help their parents and workers are illegally paid by the piece instead of the hour. With debts to Aunt Paula of both money and gratitude to pay off, Kimberly and her mother are just barely able to make ends meet.

Kimberly’s mother speaks almost no English, so it is up to Kimberly to take care of any interactions that occur outside the factory, Chinatown, or home. In Hong Kong, Kimberly was at the top of her class; in America, she can hardly understand what the teachers are saying. Her cheap clothes and foreign habits draw ridicule from her classmates, and her poor grades are discouraging.

But Kimberly is determined to help her mother, to get them both out of their current situation and build a better life for them in America, where they’ve dreamed for so long of living. Girl in Translation is Kimberly’s story.

My Thoughts:

The entire time I was listening to Girl in Translation, I had to keep reminding myself I was listening to fiction, not fact. The novel reads like a memoir, so well told that I kept forgetting, losing myself in Kimberly’s story. When I visited Jean Kwok’s website, I realized why the story felt so real: much (though not all) of what the main character experiences is autobiographical. Somehow, knowing that the novel contained kernels of truth from Kwok’s own life made the story even more powerful for me.

Kimberly is an eloquent narrator. She speaks her mind well and spares the reader nothing about her and her mother’s grim existence. She is determined and passionate, while at the same time, she is a girl who wishes she could be like other girls her age. Kwok does an excellent job showing Kimberly’s progress, especially in English. As the novel begins, Kimberly often mishears what people say to her, and Kwok simulates Kimberly’s confusion by writing what the character hears. As Kimberly learns, her English gets better and better.

I liked the way Kwok flavored her novel with Chinese. There is no actual Chinese, yet customs and traditions come up from time to time and are always explained. The novel is also full of Chinese idioms, used when the characters are supposed to be speaking Chinese and translated via Kimberly’s explanation into English for the reader. I’ve always loved idioms and really enjoyed hearing some Chinese ones.

The audio production was really good. Grayce Wey reads with a mild Chinese accent throughout, which helps create Kimberly’s voice very clearly. As Kimberly relates her story, Wey uses a much heavier accent when Kimberly has first arrived in New York. By the end of the novel, Wey reads Kimberly’s speech in the same accent she uses to narrate the rest of Kimberly’s story. I think the skill with which Wey read Girl in Translation contributed to my feeling that I was listening to a true personal story and not a novel.

Girl in Translation is a wonderful novel and audiobook. I think either would be a great way to experience Kimberly’s powerful story.

Your Turn!

Have you ever read a novel that seemed like a memoir? Was it meant to be autobiographical, or was it purely fiction?

Worth sharing?
Tweet about this on TwitterPin on PinterestShare on FacebookShare on Google+Buffer this page

Comments on this entry are closed.

  • http://bibliophilebythesea.blogspot.com/ Bibliophile By the Sea

    I loved the audio version of this book. What a strong girl Kimberly was.

    • Erin

      She was. I can’t believe how caught up in her story I got, especially with Wey narrating!

  • http://www.ragingbibliomania.net/ zibilee

    I loved this book as well, and had no idea that a lot of it was based on the author’s life! I found myself very caught up in this book and it brought out a lot of strong emotions in me. I am glad to hear you liked it too! Very insightful review!

    • Erin

      I was surprised by the autobiographical piece as well — it wasn’t until after I’d read the book and was perusing the author’s site that I found that piece out! I got very caught up too. I hardly took my headphones off :-)

  • http://www.jeankwok.com Jean Kwok

    Thank you so much for this lovely review of the audio book! I don’t have time to highlight all reviews but I’ve linked to this one on my Facebook Fan Page:

    http://www.facebook.com/pages/Jean-Kwok/213583280524

    I appreciate this very much!

    Best,
    Jean

    • Erin

      My pleasure! Thank you so much for stopping by, and for taking the time to post this review on your Facebook page!

  • http://eatthebooks.com Bookeater [aka Emily]

    I’m also listening to this audiobook right now and have heard fantastic things about it!

    • Erin

      I hope you love it!

  • http://lifewithbooks.com Jenners

    I’m sure this works really well on audio… And how cool that the author visited you!

    • Erin

      Quite :-) It did work very well on audio, especially with this particular pairing of narrator and text.

  • http://homeofaimala.blogspot.com/ Amy

    I’ve seen this book around the blogging community but didn’t know what it was about until now. I really like your description of Kimberley, I imagine while reading her story I’d be rooting for her to succeed almost from the first page.
    I’m going to add this book to my tbr list!

    ~ Amy

    • Erin

      Kimberly is exactly the sort of character you’re cheering for all the way. I couldn’t believe how wrapped up in her story I got. I hope you enjoy it!

  • http://lifewithbooks.com Jenners

    Oh … and I keep meaning to tell you and keep forgetting (because it got buried under other stuff on my desk), I did get Moonlight Mile. Thanks so much!!! Sorry it took me so long to tell you!!!

    • Erin

      I’m glad it got there! Thanks for letting me know. Enjoy!

  • http://www.reviewsbylola.wordpress.com Stephanie

    I have seen this book around a lot and at first I was a bit skeptical. I think the cover tricks me into thinking it’s chick lit. I have decided I want to read it at some point though.

    • Erin

      I had seen it around and was uninterested, too! It does look like chick lit, but it’s definitely not. It’s such a good story with a main character you can totally get behind, which I love.

  • http://booksnyc.blogspot.com Colleen (Books in the City)

    I am hosting the Immigrant Stories Challenge in 2011 and this book is perfect for it! I will add it to the list of books for the challenge on my website. Thanks for the review!

    • Erin

      Yay! It’s a wonderful book and would fit your challenge well. I hope you enjoy it!