Thoughts on “The Painted Veil” by W. Somerset Maugham

W. Somerset Maugham is an author I quite enjoy, so I’ve been collecting his books as I’ve come across them. The Painted Veil is the fifth book I’ve read from my TBR Pile Challenge list.

About the Book:

The Painted Veil by W. Somerset Maugham (erinreads.com)Kitty may not be clever or deep, but she is beautiful and well bred. In her prime, she was the apple of her mother’s eye and virtually guaranteed a marvelous marriage — only she waited too long to choose a husband from amongst her many suitors. Drifting farther and farther from prime marriageable age and desperate to land herself a husband, Kitty settles on Walter Fane, a bacteriologist on leave from his post in Hong Kong. He is dreadfully dull, but he idolizes her, and she blithely assumes that will be enough.

It isn’t, of course. Once the couple is back in Hong Kong, Kitty takes up with the charming Charles Townsend, the Assistant Colonial Secretary and a married man. She believes she loves Charlie, that he is equally devoted to her and would gladly leave his wife to be with her.

Then Walter discovers her affair, and Kitty’s pretty little world comes crashing down around her. She slowly comes to understand that she must choose between withering away in despair and growing toward a light she is only just discovering.

My Thoughts:

Though I’ve very much enjoyed all three of Maugham’s works I’ve read so far (The Razor’s Edge and The Trembling of a Leaf being the other two), I think The Painted Veil is my favorite. It feels more immediate somehow, less like a story keenly observed and more like one fully lived.

I’d expected a love story, probably because of the photograph on the cover of the movie edition I have. It’s not at all. It’s a story about a shallow woman who, faced with hardship, learns how to wake up and step into her life.

Maugham is always adept at creating great characters, but Kitty is a masterpiece. Not only is she fully formed when the novel starts — you feel you know her from the first page — she also undergoes quite a transformation as it moves forward. By the end, you’d hardly recognize her as the same woman if you hadn’t witnessed her journey.

I kept waiting for Kitty to do something frustratingly predictable. There were so many moments in which the book could have taken a turn toward the trite, when Kitty could have chosen a life that might have been easier for Maugham to write but that would have been wrong for her. I should have had more faith in Maugham. Kitty was true to herself, as a person and as a character, from start to finish, and her growth felt satisfyingly real. Maugham carefully articulated just enough of her thoughts and feelings to make the progression seem genuine, even without using a first-person point of view. And though I didn’t know until the final pages where Kitty would end up, when I found out I could imagine nothing better for her.

There are many nameless, faceless characters thronging the pages of The Painted Veil, but aside from Kitty, there aren’t many who figure prominently. Of course there are Walter Fane and Charlie Townsend, foils in many ways but not to the point of seeming contrived. There is a friend Kitty makes in her travels, and a pair of nuns as well. Kitty’s family — mother, father, and sister — are distant echoes, for the most part. Though well drawn, these characters pale in comparison with Kitty. She herself looms large, as she should.

The Painted Veil is a surprisingly quick read. It’s under 250 pages and not particularly dense. Maugham’s writing is very readable. For all that, it seems somehow to be ahead of its time. First published in 1924, it almost reads like a contemporary novel. In fact, you could probably change the places and events to the present day and the story would still work. Maugham has seized on something universal and given it to Kitty, in her time and place, to develop. She plays the part admirably.

The Verdict: Excellent

If it isn’t obvious yet, I liked The Painted Veil quite a bit. It’s certainly made me want to continue leisurely reading my way through Maugham’s titles. I would definitely recommend this one to readers who are new to Maugham as well as those who already know and love him.

Your Turn!

What books have you read that rely heavily on just a main character or two? Do they do so successfully?

Thoughts on “The ACB with Honora Lee” by Kate De Goldi

I received a copy of The ACB with Honora Lee by Kate De Goldi via LibraryThing’s Early Reviewers program. It’s short and illustrated, which made it a perfect read for the late hours of last month’s readathon!

About the Book:

The ACB with Honora Lee by Kate De Goldi (erinreads.com)Perry’s parents keep her busy. She has piano lessons and clarinet lessons and Music and Movement class and tutoring. On Fridays, the rare day Perry doesn’t have something to do after school, she gets to go straight home to her nanny, Nina, and Nina’s son Claude. Nina is an excellent baker, and Perry and Claude have fun playing together.

On Saturday mornings, Perry and her dad go to the Santa Lucia rest home to visit her grandmother, Honora Lee. Gran loves the alphabet, though she never remembers who Perry and her father are. Perry doesn’t really mind. She’s intrigued by Gran. When Music and Movement class is cancelled mid-year and Perry needs a new after-school activity, her parents reluctantly decide she can visit Gran by herself on those days instead. Perry becomes a regular fixture at the rest home, getting to know the staff and the patients and ultimately working them all into the alphabet book she creates.

My Thoughts:

I found The ACB with Honora Lee to be…nice. Fine. Lots of bland, noncommittal adjectives. It’s written for young readers, so my expectations weren’t particularly high. Still, despite being generally ok, The ACB with Honora Lee was lacking the sparkle and pull of other middle-grade novels I’ve read. It felt very much like a straight line, without a climax or low point or any other shape, for that matter, to be found. Which, I suppose, isn’t a problem. It’s just not what I’m used to.

What I thought De Goldi did very well was create her characters. It didn’t take her long at all to give each one a personality of his or her own. Everyone from Perry to her impersonal parents to her teachers to her nanny to the people at Santa Lucia was impressively unique for having appeared in an illustrated 124-page novel with big print. Perry was my favorite. You get a taste of her personality right off the bat from passages like this one, on the second page:

‘Maybe bumblebees are just getting stupider,’ said Perry. She was thinking of becoming a zoologist when she grew up.

‘There’s no such word as stupider,’ said both her parents together.

Perry looked up from the picture she was drawing. (It was a spider making a web.)

‘There is now,’ she said.

The writing itself is clever for the reading level, and I really had no complaints there. The way De Goldi uses language is, at least in part, why she can create such charming characters, I think. It’s just that the story in which those charmingly drawn characters were set felt flat.

The illustrations, while whimsical, got on my nerves a bit because they were inconsistent. Sometimes they seemed to represent the drawings Perry was making in the story, while other times they illustrated something that was happening in the story itself. Either one would have been lovely, but the mix got a little frustrating. It seems like a missed opportunity, somehow. I stopped paying attention to them midway through.

Overall, I can see how the intended audience for this novel would enjoy it. It wasn’t quite my cup of tea. I’ve heard Kate De Goldi’s other books are good, but I’m not in any rush to run out and read them.

The Verdict: Mediocre

If you’re a big fan of middle-grade fiction, or if you have a young reader who is getting into chapter books, The ACB with Honora Lee might work nicely for you. However, for general adult readers, I’d give this particular novel a pass.

Your Turn!

What’s your favorite middle-grade novel?

Thoughts on “Eleanor & Park” by Rainbow Rowell (Audiobook)

I picked up Eleanor & Park by Rainbow Rowell on a recent trip to the library because the cover looked familiar and I needed an audiobook for last month’s readathon. When I posted my readathon stack, Jenny responded by saying:

“Eleanor and Park is amazing and you are living a half-life until you have read it. (I am exaggerating but not, like, THAT much.)”

So I figured I’d chosen well!

About the Book:

Eleanor & Park by Rainbow Rowell audiobook (erinreads.com)Park hates riding the school bus. He’d be driving himself to school by now if only his dad wasn’t forcing him to learn to drive a stick shift before he can get his license. He loses himself in comic books and homemade mix tapes every day in an attempt to drown out the obnoxious kids — many of whom Park grew up with — who sit at the back of the bus.

Then one day, a new girl gets on the bus. She has wild red hair, is overweight, and has a sense of fashion that pretty much kills any chance of her first day going well. The seats were all claimed on the first day of school, and no one who snagged a seat to themselves — Park included — is willing to take the social hit that inviting the new girl to sit with them would cause. But she stands there for so long, so awkwardly, that Park caves. The new girl slides into his seat. And nothing will ever be the same for either of them.

My Thoughts:

I’ll start by warning that if you know nothing about the book at all, and you don’t care to, this review may by necessity get a little spoiler-y. Continue at your own risk!

Jenny didn’t lie. Eleanor & Park is an excellent book. It’s told in alternating limited third-person voices, sometimes from Eleanor’s perspective and sometimes from Park’s. That approach works really well in this case, since it has the dual effect of zooming the story in tight on the two title characters and making sure all the important events get covered by an eyewitness. The book feels like a cozy little bubble, like you’re firmly ensconced in the sphere of Park and Eleanor’s relationship, a fly on the wall. At the same time, you also get to experience the stuff that happens when they’re not together. The flow between the two just works.

Park and Eleanor are so remarkably real. Rowell must have taken notes when she was a teenager, because the things her characters say and do and think and feel are so vivid and ring so true. They are people you know like your own best friend by the time the novel is over. Their relationship, too, develops in such a natural and lovely way that you can’t help but smile along. The fragility and awkwardness are endearingly real.

The other characters take on a satisfying amount of personality and life through Park and Eleanor’s eyes, too, providing the book with a strong supporting cast. I think Park’s mom might have been my favorite. That, or Eleanor’s two gym class friends. Together the secondary characters provide a realistic context for the centerpiece of Eleanor and Park.

There are some tough parts of the book. Eleanor’s home life is far from ideal; it often borders on dangerous. She doesn’t have an easy time of it at school, either, where her outcast status continues to draw malice from many of the other kids. I thought Rowell dealt with both very skillfully, neither holding back nor gratuitously inserting incidents that added nothing to the story. The hard things were an important aspect of the story, but I don’t think they were the point.

The audiobook was perfect. Readers Rebecca Lowman (who read Annie on My Mind by Nancy Garden, which I adored) and Sunil Malhotra were fantastic as Eleanor and Park, respectively. And having the two characters’ sections actually read by two different people brought the story to life in a way I don’t think could have been achieved quite so well in print or with a single narrator.

I was not a hundred percent satisfied with the ending, which was my only complaint. I don’t know what I expected. I actually spent most of the book terrified that something awful was going to happen at any moment, so I should have been relieved. I guess I needed to know that Eleanor and Park were going to be ok, and I didn’t quite get enough reassurance. Still, it could have ended much worse. It’s a tiny, minor quibble compared to how much I enjoyed the book as a whole.

The Verdict: Excellent

I’m sold. Thanks, Jenny! I’m also curious now to read more from Rainbow Rowell. If Eleanor & Park is a good representation of her work, I know I’ll like the others.

Your Turn!

What books have you read that brought a particular age or experience vividly to life?

Thoughts on “Ella Minnow Pea” by Mark Dunn

Ella Minnow Pea by Mark Dunn has been on my radar (and my shelves) for years. It’s been recommended to me by several people whose reading opinions I trust. So when I put together my TBR Pile Challenge list, I made sure Ella Minnow Pea was on it.

About the Book:

Ella Minnow Pea by Mark Dunn cover (erinreads.com)Ella Minnow Pea lives on the island of Nollop, where Nevin Nollop — native son and inventor of that famous pangram, “The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog” — is revered. There is a monument to him in Nollop’s capital, above which his famous sentence is spelled out in alphabet titles.

Then one day, a single tile falls from the sentence and shatters on the ground below: “z.” What does it mean? The Council members call an emergency meeting to discuss the situation. Their decision sets Nollop on a slippery slope toward the destruction of language, the very thing Nollop prides itself for.

The story unfolds in letters between Ella, her cousin Tassie, both girls’ mothers, as well as assorted other family and community members. Through them, the consequences of the Council’s decision play out in real time as Nollop’s inhabitants fight to save the very language they cherish.

My Thoughts:

Ella Minnow Pea really is delightful. If you’re one of the people who has nudged me to read it over the past few years, thank you! It’s an odd blend of deliciously erudite language and quick, entertaining story. At just over 200 pages, it makes for a short but satisfying little read, too.

The epistolary format is ingenious. First, it keeps the novel short and compact. There are no long descriptions of past events or present environments because they aren’t relevant. It’s focused on what’s happening because that is what’s on the characters’ minds. (This is also a shortcoming, to me, as I’ll explain in a moment, but it serves what I believe to be Dunn’s intent quite well.) Second, it lets you, as the reader, see exactly what happens as letters drop from the monument and the Council makes its decrees. Without saying too much in the way of spoilers, I was both dazzled by the creativity the author employed through his characters and slightly horrified by the thought of such a thing actually coming to pass.

If you think too hard about it, the parallels you can draw to issues like censorship or the blind following of a leader are scary. No doubt you can read Ella Minnow Pea as a warning parable; despite its fun exterior, it seems well suited to that. I chose not to go there during the readathon, when my main focus was — unsurprisingly — to read. But now it’s gnawing at the back corners of my mind as something worth looking at again. There’s a darker side underlying the jolly surface, I think.

I had only one complaint. Let me preface it by saying I think the author achieved the sort of book he was going for and that therefore, what I’m about to say is more a matter of personal preference than any shortcoming of Dunn’s. Despite all its linguistic play and clever allegorical potential, Ella Minnow Pea struck me as shallow in terms of character and story. You learn a handful of facts about each character, but none of the people who turn up in the novel’s pages has any depth. They are, primarily, vehicles through which the Council’s decrees and their impact on Nollopian society can unfold. The story is focused entirely on those decrees and their impact, which is certainly understandable given their scope and severity. I have no trouble believing they would be front and center in the characters’ minds. But there’s basically no fluff to pad the tale into a well-rounded story. As I said, I think that was the author’s intent rather than something he achieved inadvertently. Personally, I believe it would have been even more fascinating with a little more meat on its bones. It’s still quite an enjoyable book; just don’t expect a character- and story-rich novel to sink your teeth into.

The Verdict: Enjoyable

If you like clever wordplay, epistolary formats, or a bit of whimsey and imagination in the novels you read, you really can’t go wrong with Ella Minnow Pea by Mark Dunn. Added bonus: it’s a quick read!

Your Turn!

What’s your favorite novel in which the language itself is particularly engaging?

Bout of Books: Updates

Bout of BooksBout of Books has begun! This post will house my updates for the whole week. I’ll keep running totals for the week up top and add each day’s notes at the end.

Weekly Totals

Hours read: 9 hours, 53 minutes
Pages read:
  462
Books finished:

  • The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro
  • The Space Between Us by Thrity Umrigar

Hours listened: 39 hours, 42 minutes
Audiobooks finished:

  • Son of a Witch by Gregory Maguire (though I only had a couple of discs left when the event began!)
  • A Lion Among Men by Gregory Maguire
  • Out of Oz by Gregory Maguire

Monday

Hours read: 1 hour, 6 minutes
Pages read: 64
Books read: The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro

Hours listened: 4 hours, 31 minutes
Books listened to: Son of a Witch and A Lion Among Men by Gregory Maguire

I’d meant to do more reading and less listening today, but hours spent with books in any form are better than hours not spent with books! Hopefully I’ll get more actual reading done tomorrow. I’ve been making good progress on the Gregory Maguire audiobooks, at least.

Tuesday

Hours read: 2 hours, 16 minutes
Pages read: 113
Books read: The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro and The Space Between Us by Thrity Umrigar

Hours listened: 3 hours, 14 minutes
Books listened to: A Lion Among Men by Gregory Maguire

I got through the last 100 pages of The Remains of the Day today and made it into disc 8 of 10 of A Lion Among Men. Hooray! Now to choose my next book…I think I’ll go with The Space Between Us by Thrity Umrigar.

Wednesday

Hours read: 1 hour, 49 minutes
Pages read: 76
Books read: The Space Between Us by Thrity Umrigar

Hours listened: 3 hours, 11 minutes
Books listened to: A Lion Among Men and Out of Oz by Gregory Maguire

My least productive day so far, at least in terms of reading. Still, I’ve knocked two titles off my list and am enjoying the two I’m working on now! And 5 hours of reading and listening combined isn’t too shabby, I suppose.

Thursday

Hours read: 1 hour, 26 minutes
Pages read: 65
Books read: The Space Between Us by Thrity Umrigar

Hours listened: 4 hours, 20 minutes
Books listened to: Out of Oz by Gregory Maguire

Another day heavier on listening than reading. I suppose that’s the theme of this readathon for me! I’m certainly on track to meet my goal of reading/listening more than I usually do, at least.

Friday

Hours read: 1 hour, 26 minutes
Pages read: 71
Books read: The Space Between Us by Thrity Umrigar

Hours listened: 3 hours, 50 minutes
Books listened to: Out of Oz by Gregory Maguire

Saturday

Hours Minutes read: 20 minutes
Pages read: 11
Books read: The Space Between Us by Thrity Umrigar

Hours listened: 8 hours, 47 minutes
Books listened to: Out of Oz by Gregory Maguire

It was definitely an audiobook day! I’m just a couple of discs away from finishing the 23-disc Out of Oz, which is pretty exciting. I’ll definitely get through that today. And I’m about 60 pages away from the end of The Space Between Us, which is also awesome!

Sunday

Hours read: 1 hour, 30 minutes
Pages read: 62
Books read: The Space Between Us by Thrity Umrigar, Strawberry Fields by Marina Lewycka

Hours listened: 11 hours, 49 minutes
Books listened to: Out of Oz by Gregory Maguire, The World According to Garp by John Irving

11 hours and 49 minutes of straight listening yesterday! Whoa. I finished both of the books I’d hoped to finish by the end of the readathon and started two more. Yay!